Tribhovandas Bhimji Zaveri: First day Flop Show, Share loses over 7%

 

Shares of Tribovandas Bhimji Zaveri Limited (TBZ) listed on the BSE and NSE yesterday. The company had tapped the capital markets with its IPO during the 24th and 26th of April. The price band was Rs 120-126. The company had also made an allocation of 24.99 lac shares to three anchor investors at the lower end of the price band of Rs 120. The issue overall just about managed to get subscribed with the help of friendly HNI’s who subscribed their portion 1.91 times. Retail portion remained undersubscribed and received support for 68% of their quota. The asking price was expensive and though the company is 146 years old, it by and large remains a Mumbai dominated, Western India company.

Exchange Open High Low Close Net Change % Gain/loss Wt. Avg Volume Delivery Del %age
BSE 115.00 119.80 110.00 111.20 -8.80 -7.33 112.29 1157716 1157716 100.00
NSE 115.05 120.00 110.50 111.00 -9.00 -7.50 112.15 1253983 1253983 100.00
Total 2411699 2411699 100.00

The discovered price after the 45 minute call auction was Rs 115 on the BSE. The share opened at Rs 115 and was under pressure throughout the day. The high and low on the BSE was Rs 119.80 and Rs 110 respectively. These prices were seen at the beginning of the day itself with the high happening in the pre-open session and the low within the first few minutes of trade. On the NSE the similar prices were Rs 120 as the high and Rs 110.50 as the low and again these prices happened in a similar fashion as the BSE.

The share traded under pressure throughout the day and the broad trading range was centred around Rs 112 with a movement of one rupee on either side making it a range of between Rs 111-113. The trading volume considering it is and would remain for the next nine days under trade to trade category reasonable at 24.11 lac shares. This is 14.47% of the shares issued at 166.67 lac shares. The weighted average of the day’s trade was Rs 112.29 at the BSE and Rs 112.15 at the NSE. The closing price of the share was Rs 111.20 on the BSE, a loss of Rs 8.80 or 7.33%. On the NSE the closing price was Rs 111, a loss of Rs 9 or 7.50%.

The above price chart shows the day’s trade on BSE. The trade was fairly range bound and on a low key. As mentioned before the issue was just about subscribed and was expensive compared to its listed peers offering little scope for appreciation. The markets whether one talks of the primary or secondary markets, are not in the best of health and this added to the subscription woes.

All in all the first day listing of TBZ leaves a lot to be desired. Investors who have applied will have to hold on to their shares before they are able to recover their investment price. Investors looking to enter the share now that the uncertainty of listing and the price thereafter is over should wait for some time and further weakness before entering the scrip.

The record books would say that yet another IPO, yet another listing and yet another poor show. The day when investors are happy because the issue was reasonably priced seem to be far away.

Samvardhana Motherson Finance: IPO Withdrawn

The IPO from SamvardhanaMotherson Finance Limited (SMFL) which had tapped the capital markets to raise Rs 1,665 crs was withdrawn at the end of the 3rd Day after receiving very poor response to the issue. The issue was subscribed under a fourth and almost all of the same came from QIB’s. The HNI, Retail and Shareholder portion were subscribed a mere 1% each.

What is most unfortunate is that with half the issue reserved for retail and HNI’s, this category was not wooed or explained properly what the benefits of investing in the company are.

The company held its road show in Mumbai on the 24th of April, but very inappropriately decided not to announce the price band. An analyst meet for an upcoming IPO without a price band is a meaningless exercise and it puts off people attending the event as being a waste of time. It also sends a wrong signal to the market participants that the price band is not being announced simply because the management and merchant bankers want to hide something. This could also mean that the price is unjustified and hence they want to avoid discussion on an issue which would in any case turn out be self-defeating. If the merchant bankers and promoters believed that the price was expensive and hence did not announce the same in Mumbai, they have already killed the issue even before it completed its road shows.

The secondary markets have been doing badly for some time now and the primary markets have been worse. If the markets are to be revived you need a mega issue which is reasonably priced, makes money for its investors and therefore helps in restoring confidence. There was an opportunity in SMFL to do this. Here was an issue with had size as the same was raising Rs 1,665 crs. It was from the Auto Ancillary space and if there is one sector which has done well in the last 12-15 months it is the Auto sector. There is only one other sector which has done well and that is the FMCG sector. This company is a virtual mirror image company to SMFL in the form of MothersonSumi Systems Limited and that company is in existence now for 19 years having an excellent track record. The asking price for SMFL was substantially higher than MothersonSumi and therefore the response from investors was extremely poor.

The Indian Rupee has depreciated very sharply in the last few weeks and this would have been a great advantage for foreign investors as they would have to invest fewer dollars for the same amount of Indian Rupees. One believes this issue having being withdrawn is a big blow to the primary market and it is time that promoters and merchant bankers get their act today. It is high time that they realise that pricing is the key to the success of an issue. A primary market issue has risks compared to a secondary market security. If there is an apt comparable there is no way that the primary market issue could be at a premium valuation to the secondary market.

The revival of the primary market is unfortunately in the hands of merchant bankers and promoters, and it is a tragedy that neither of them want to become lessgreedy or leave something for investors on the table so that they make some money. In such a scenario it is best for prospective investors in the primary market to shun every issue which comes to the market place until and unless it is offered real cheap. Unfortunately that day may simply not come.

Performance of Newly Listed Shares as on 4th May 2012

Name Date of listing Issue Price closing  price closing price % gain loss  change over
27th April 27th April over week  lssue price
Olympic Card 28th March 30.00 29.85 28.85 3.33 -0.50
NBCC 12th April 106.00 90.05 95.85 -5.47 -15.05
MT Educare 12th April 80.00 98.15 111.00 -16.06 22.69
Subscribe to RSS Feed Follow me on Twitter!